A Tricky Transition: Can Good Writers Become Competent Editors?
by Steven Threndyle
Veteran freelance writers exhausted by the endless cycles of feast or famine often reach a point in their career where they fantasize, “I want one of those cush editing jobs!”
And why not? The most prestigious editors sit atop the magazine pyramid as creative overseers. Like chief executive officers who hop from one brand to the next, an executive editor (or editor-in-chief) of an A-list magazine is a personality in his or her own right; entrusted to steer the magazine in a profitable direction while ensuring high standards of journalistic integrity.
The best ones also get to bring home the hardware during awards season.
But can writers simply slip into the editor’s chair? Do strong writing skills automatically translate into editorial talent?
Jim Sutherland, former editor of both Western Living and Vancouver magazine, offers some encouragement—and a warning. “There’s a certain kind of free-spirited writer who is probably not going to be offered an editorial job. Otherwise, editors and writers share way more similarities than differences.”
The path from writer to editor
Vancouver freelancer social night June 26
Vancouver-area freelancers, come out and celebrate the start of summer at a casual social evening on Tuesday, June 26 from 6 to 8 p.m. at Central City Brewpub (871 Beatty St).
CMG Freelance members and non-members are all welcome to drop by this semi-regular gathering for drinks, snacks and conversation. It’s an opportunity to catch up with some old freelance friends or meet a few new ones.
Whether you’re having problems and could use some advice or you’re just in need of some time away from your desk, come out for a little freelance camaraderie and build your professional network.
Please RSVP to freelance@cmg.ca to let us know if you can make it. Hope to see you there!
Off the Wire: News for the Canadian media freelancer June 5-11
Once a week, we gather stories about the media business, journalism, writing, communications, and freelancing—with a Canadian focus—and share them in Off the Wire. Who needs a water cooler?
From Canada:
- Black Press to print Calgary Sun; 52 Postmedia positions to be eliminated [CTV News]
- How youth activism is kicking unpaid internships to the curb [The Conversation]
- Canadian journalism students’ interest in journalism careers lessens during course of journalism school [J-Source]
- Non-profit sector aims to create Canada’s first national, portable retirement plan [Toronto Star]
From The U.S. and beyond:
- Eight 21st Century Tips for Writing Better Articles [Freelance Writing Jobs]
- The Freelancer’s Guide to Building a Home Office That Works [The Freelancer]
- The New Yorker Joins a Growing List of Media Companies to Unionize [New York Times]
- The secret ingredient to being a freelancer: Being yourself [Being Freelance]
- How to get faster payments from your clients [Freelancers Union]
Recently on Story Board:
- Freelancers invited to VICE networking event in Toronto June 14: The event will be a chance for freelancers at all stages of their careers to speak with editors and participate in a panel discussion about careers in journalism and freelancing…
- Largest-ever freelance delegation attends 2018 CMG convention: CMG Freelance’s six executive members plus five delegates and one observer spent time together in branch meetings and participated in the union’s plenary sessions…
Spot a story you think we should include in next week’s Off the Wire? Email the link to editor@thestoryboard.ca or tweet us at @storyboard_ca.
Freelancers invited to VICE networking event in Toronto June 14
Freelancers are invited to a VICE networking event in Toronto later this month.
VICE Hustle: Editorial happens on Thursday, June 14 from 5 pm to 7 pm at 78 Mowat Avenue.
The event will be a chance for freelancers at all stages of their careers to speak with editors and participate in a panel discussion about careers in journalism and freelancing.
VICE says the event is intended to offer freelancers a chance to network and build their confidence and to increase transparency among Toronto’s freelance writers.
“If you’re new to the game and want to know where to start, this is the place,” says VICE. “If you’ve been in the trenches for a while and want to pester editors in person rather than over email, this is also the place.”
This event is free to attend, but please RSVP here: vicehustle.splashthat.com.
Largest-ever freelance delegation attends 2018 CMG convention
Last month the largest-ever delegation of freelancers came together to represent CMG Freelance at the Canadian Media Guild’s 2018 biennial convention in Toronto.
Approximately 175 people from 11 branches of the union — including CBC, Thomson Reuters, VICE Canada, Aboriginal Peoples Television Network and Canadian Press — attended the convention from May 25 to 27 at the Marriott Bloor Yorkville Hotel.
CMG Freelance’s six executive members plus five delegates and one observer spent time together in branch meetings and participated in the union’s plenary sessions.
CMG Freelance president Don Genova said he was heartened by the level of support that CMG Freelance received from delegates and other branches of the union.
“We’re moving forward to develop some guidelines that will help our fellow brothers and sisters at other employers think of our members first when it comes to allowable hiring outside of their collective agreements,” he said.
Genova also said the convention was an opportunity to learn about problems individual members are having with pay and working conditions.
Off the Wire: News for the Canadian media freelancer May 29-June 4
Once a week, we gather stories about the media business, journalism, writing, communications, and freelancing—with a Canadian focus—and share them in Off the Wire. Who needs a water cooler?
From Canada:
- Announcing the winners of the 41st annual National Magazine Awards [Magazine Awards]
- How to succeed in digital journalism from the DPAs Emerging Excellence finalists [J-Source]
- The Site receives Magazine Grand Prix from the National Magazine Awards [Canadian Magazines]
- Inside a small town newsroom during a time of news poverty [J-Source]
From The U.S. and beyond:
- 5 tips for breaking the freelance feast or famine cycle [Freelancers Union]
- Why all writers should learn SEO basics [The Freelancer]
- Three clauses freelancers should know (and negotiate), according to lawyers [CJR]
- 5 financial lessons to learn early in your career [Freelancers Union]
- Global call for action to end worldwide discrimination and abuse of women journalists [IFJ]
- The 4 P’s of podcasting: How to turn your idea into an audio hit [Journalism.co.uk]
Recently on Story Board:
- Systematic Editing for the Uncomfortable / Nervous / Reluctant / Insecure Editor: I recently took an all-day Eight-Step Editing workshop with my local chapter of Editors Canada. As well as nudging me into a systematic approach for editing both my own and workplace documents, I was surprised to also pick up some useful writing tips…
Spot a story you think we should include in next week’s Off the Wire? Email the link to editor@thestoryboard.ca or tweet us at @storyboard_ca.
Systematic Editing for the Uncomfortable / Nervous / Reluctant / Insecure Editor
by Amanda Maxwell 
Editing a piece of work isn’t my favourite occupation. If it’s my own, then word blindness and over-familiarity settles in. If it’s for someone else, then I panic about changing their voice.
Most of the time I sort-of know when something’s not right, but not always how to fix it. And this hasn’t changed much; editing courses usually leave me confused and demoralized so I’ve avoided them. At the risk of annoying all the writing instructors I’ve taken classes from, I admit I’m still reading aloud and switching to Comic Sans as my basic only method.
Unlike a carefully crafted narrative, my editing approach has no beginning, middle or end as I dot between lines, paragraphs and pages
However, my approach is slowly changing.
I recently took an all-day Eight-Step Editing workshop with my local chapter of Editors Canada. As well as nudging me into a systematic approach for editing both my own and workplace documents, I was surprised to also pick up some useful writing tips.
Editors Canada has run the Eight-Step Editing workshops since 1985 alongside its full certification programs. Describing Eight-Step Editing as “breaking down the editorial process into a series of tasks,” the organization promotes the workshops to three audiences:
Off the Wire: News for the Canadian media freelancer May 23-28
Once a week, we gather stories about the media business, journalism, writing, communications, and freelancing—with a Canadian focus—and share them in Off the Wire. Who needs a water cooler?
From Canada:
- Bloggers and commenters fund a journalism fellowship on behalf of one of their own [J-Source]
- Media Union Condemns Attempted Intimidation of VICE Journalists [CMG]
- CWA Canada stands with VICE as source protection case goes to Supreme Court [CWA Canada]
From The U.S. and beyond:
- How to become your editor’s favourite writer [The Freelancer]
- Critics and online outlets lead the vanguard in arts writing [Nieman Lab]
- There are no limits to audio storytelling: 10 tips for podcasting beginners [Journalism.co.uk]
- Blocking, shoving the latest in rough treatment of journalists [Poynter]
- How to Stay True to Your Journalism Ethics in the World of Content Marketing [The Freelancer]
- 3 obstacles that hold creatives back (and how to overcome them) [Freelancers Union]
- Freelancers recovering stolen wages under new NYC law [Next City]
- No filter: The importance of light when you’re taking photos with your smartphone [Journalism.co.uk]
- Keeping your overhead low and your profit margin high [Freelancers Union]
Recently on Story Board:
- 2018 Portenier Human Rights Bursary competition open for applications: Freelance journalists and independent documentary makers working on projects that focus on human rights abuses can apply for the bursary, which provides the winner with $3000 to attend hostile environment training…
- The Born Freelancer Asks: Are We Notoriously Lazy?: The accusation took me completely by surprise. I was once in casual discussions with an industry insider about the conditions under which we might work together on a number of future projects — me as a writer and he in a non-creative administrative capacity…
Spot a story you think we should include in next week’s Off the Wire? Email the link to editor@thestoryboard.ca or tweet us at @storyboard_ca.
2018 Portenier Human Rights Bursary competition open for applications
2015 Portenier winner Jason O’Hara, a Toronto-based documentary filmmaker
Applications are now open for the 2018 Portenier Human Rights Bursary competition. Freelance journalists and independent documentary makers working on projects that focus on human rights abuses can apply for the bursary, which provides the winner with $3000 to attend hostile environment training.
The bursary is offered by the Canadian Journalism Forum on Violence and Trauma, which also offers a number of training bursaries each year through the Forum Freelance Fund.
The application deadline is June 15th. Winners will be notified by July 31st and must choose a course from the list of approved course providers by September 30th. Applicants may be of any nationality. Approved courses are currently available in Canada, the USA, Britain, Afghanistan and sometimes elsewhere.
For more information on how to apply, see the Canadian Journalism Forum on Violence and Trauma’s website.
The Born Freelancer Asks: Are We Notoriously Lazy?
This series of posts by the Born Freelancer shares personal experiences and thoughts on issues relevant to freelancers. Have something to add to the conversation? We’d love to hear from you in the comments.
The accusation took me completely by surprise.
I was once in casual discussions with an industry insider about the conditions under which we might work together on a number of future projects — me as a writer and he in a non-creative administrative capacity.
As the informal negotiations went back and forth it occurred to me his proposed management style was extremely obsessive. When I gently pointed out that he was proposing, in fact, to micromanage the entire writing process (something I would argue best left to writers to sort out amongst ourselves) he readily agreed.
Looking at me with complete sincerity and without a trace of humour he added, “Well, of course I have to micromanage you. You freelance writers are notoriously lazy”.
He then smiled good-naturedly as if he had expressed some fundamental human truth and went on to other issues – but I couldn’t let it pass. It was as if he had punched me in the stomach. What had lead him to such a stereotypically negative view of our craft? Surely someone in his exalted position should have had a far better understanding of us and what we do?
Read the rest of this post »
